Saturday, March 31, 2012

Random I know...


I had to escape the puppy


He’s bigger now and he casts. I have ‘hairy throat’. Gags. 


So just kicking back today, jotting down some book ideas (no need to panic I’m still hard at work on Borrowed Ember… OK, not today, but usually!), checking emails etc.  Haunting Goodreads :-p
I have an addiction to Goodreads and I had one of those domino moments, like, oh hell - an hour and a half ago! I’ve been trolling for an hour and a half?

OK, I’ll explain what happened. I went onto Goodreads and saw on my home page that a Goodreads friend had given a book that’s releasing soon (and one I had greatly been looking forward to) a one star. *Wince*. Curious to see what could possibly be so bad about this book that it warranted a one star I checked out the review. From there I discovered ‘BAD AUTHOR BEHAVIOUR’. *Gobsmacked* seriously… this spiraled (dominoed) into discovering one YA author after another who has acted like… well, yeah, I’m just gonna say it, acted like a dick. It was like each link led me to a new one. And not just indies. No, no. The majority were traditionally published :-\
You know how this makes me feel?



Yup. Blue. I feel blue.

I wished I hadn’t read the articles but you know it was kind of like a car crash… I couldn’t look away. I was reading screenshots of authors calling reviewers bitches and other nasty words and publicly asking people to click on the ‘don’t like’ buttons on reviews from amazon and Goodreads. What the effing efferson?
I’ve deleted the books of those authors from my reading piles on principle alone. And no, it’s not just because I love bloggers (truly, I don’t know where I’d be without them) and respect their opinion whether it’s positive or constructive, but because I love the writer’s community and this dickish behavior just makes all authors look bad.
You know what makes it worse? The reviews that were attacked weren’t even that snarky or anything. Okay, a couple of them had snark but they were fair and they were constructive. Even if they’d been really mean and unnecessarily nasty, I still wouldn’t agree with an author or agent publicly reacting to the review. It’s so unprofessional. I’ve had bad reviews. I’ve even had some personal comments made against me but I either take the constructive bad reviews and use them to make my work better or I roll my eyes at the person who made an assumption about me without even knowing me. I don’t try to turn Goodreads and Twitter and Facebook into a battleground.
My question is… who exactly are these authors writing for then if they quite openly turn their noses up at YA bloggers? Don’t they know that’s who they purport to write for, who they say they want to entertain? My bullshit meter is going off… their attitude tells me they have no care for their actual readers and just want to be the next big thing.

Insert snort of derision. Uh, try getting to the big time without your YA readers, Numbnut.

*clears throat* Okay, I got a little carried away there. Sorry, I’m just still in the moment. Still shocked. Still P O’ed.

Breathe.

There are lots of awesome authors out there who are professional. I follow a lot of them - check out my sidebar. I think I can speak for them when I say we appreciate our readers, we appreciate social sites like Goodreads, Twitter and Facebook that allow us to communicate with our readers, to have fun with them and still maintain a professionalism that makes the reader feel secure in the knowledge that they’re dealing with a writer who truly takes them seriously.


OK. Moment over.



Get me a ladder, I'm coming down.







I scratched my new car today. Boo. Stupid bag with little metal corners I didn’t notice. It’s Okay… kind of. It’s a shallow scratch so I can fix it. I had a donut and it helped.

Maybe that’s how reviewers should end negative reviews:
“I didn’t enjoy your book but I’d be happy to give you a donut. It’ll help.”

It really will.

Sam x

13 comments:

  1. oh wow. Didn't know there are such authors... Hmm... Is it bad if I say I enjoyed reading that post? Even if it's about quite a bad, sad (insert negative adjectif here) topic? Well it's the truth. I just seem to like your kind of writing. Your sense of humour's great :D
    After reading this I want a donut. Seriously. Maybe I should've bought one last Friday when I kinda almost ruined my mom's car (so I can sympathize with you). Its whole right side is full of scratches... At least the car's ten years old, so not that big of a problem. (Confession time was this afternoon, when my mom returned from Toronto..)
    Okey.. I don't think anyone wants to read this.. haha... >>

    ReplyDelete
  2. @Lala - Ah, I hope your mum was OK about the car :-\ that sucks. Here... I'm giving you a virtual donut... totally not satisfying but the sentiment is there :-p

    Sam x

    ReplyDelete
  3. Well said! Oh, and when my brother scratched his car a few years ago he ate a donut too :-) Hope your car is all better soon.

    ReplyDelete
  4. @Maddy - Lol, thanks, Maddy. I'm gonna get the car fixed this week, so hopefully it will be good as new :-)

    ReplyDelete
  5. Great authors are always there for their fans bad review or not. No two people perceive things in the same light so not all reviews may be excellent. So to the naughty authors I say boo BOO to you meanie pants! I really truly adore and appreciate authors like you who talk to your readers, and even weigh our opinions too. Perhaps the naughty authors book covers should say in large bold print, I'm only in it for the money. My hats off to you, thanks for being such a wonderful person!

    ReplyDelete
  6. It really surprises me that some authors don't realize how careful the have to be with things like this. A lot of times your reputation is just as important as your writing. There are several authors that I don't read their work any more because of comments they have made about other authors or their fans. You just can't do that. Be a professional...

    ReplyDelete
  7. @HgoolsbyRN - Thank you so much :-) And I completely agree - everyone perceives things differently and that's just something an author has to accept with a little grace and dignity when it comes to reviews.

    xx

    @Keary - Thanks for weighing in, Keary. I have to admit I did wonder what other authors felt about this kind of behaviour, and it's good to know I'm not the only what kind of outraged by it. And well-said 'A lot of times your reputation is just as important as your writing.' This is so true. An immature, careless, unprofessional author immediately makes me think they've given just as much care to their writing as to the way they treat their reader... zero care... so I'll not bother with their book. I guess we thought the phrase 'Be professional' was common sense but apparently not :-\

    ReplyDelete
  8. Samantha,

    I just want to to say, as someone so new to the obsessed readers world, I can definitely tell who the non-loyal authors are and who loyal ones are, such as yourself.

    When I found your books i was immediately intrigued by the stories. When I read about you and saw just how much you give back to your readers, well.. that made me an instant fan for life. I believe in criticism and coming from the art world it's apart of my everyday life. Like you said, good or bad criticism sometimes we just need to hear it, take it for what it is and move on.

    Thank You for always giving back to you readers and letting us in on your writing journey. I believe in you and you stories! I hope to be emerged in your worlds for years to come.

    Again, Thank You Samantha Young.

    ReplyDelete
  9. @Harriet - wow, thank you so much, Harriet, I so appreciate you saying that :-D It means a lot! xx

    ReplyDelete
  10. I agree with everything you've said. It's sad that there are readers out there who can be very mean, but hey, that's life. Some people will never be happy. You can't please everyone. But you can be gracious about it. Just consider this: if someone bothers to go out of her/his way to cut you down, at least you can say you're in the same company as J.K. Rowlings, Stephenie Meyer, and every other "successful" author out there, right? :) Whenever I need to feel better about a review, I go read 1- and 2-star reviews of bestselling authors. Never fails to cheer me up! lol

    ReplyDelete
  11. @Elle - Lol! I do the exact same thing! :-D

    ReplyDelete
  12. BEST ENDING
    EVERRRRRRRR

    ReplyDelete

Questions? Comments? No? Yes? Here is the place to post them...